Cutler Cay

Cutler Cay is a waterfront community of single family homes in Cutler Bay, Florida, with a range of options priced between $995,000 and $1,950,000. There are currently a total of 8 homes for sale in Cutler Cay. The smallest Cutler Cay home presently available is a five bedroom three bathroom residence that is 3,957 square feet (3,061SF Under Air living space), and the largest of the Cutler Cay homes currently on the market has five beds and five baths and is a 5,951 square foot (5,047SF Under Air) residence.

Cutler Cay amenities include a clubhouse, swimming pool, spa / hot tub, a state-of-the-art fitness center, sauna, game room, billiards room, and hobby room. Sports facilities include tennis courts, pickleball courts, and basketball court. Onsite dining venues consist of a community kitchen, and a bar / lounge. There is also a community park, as well as a playground.

Pets are allowed in Cutler Cay. There is a limitation on pet size. Dogs are allowed.

The floor plans in Cutler Cay are among several home models such as the Assisi, Bergamo, Brescia, Florence, Florence Ii, Florence Ll, Lucca, Milan, Orvieto, Perugia, Perugia Mansion, Pisa, Siena, Sienna, and the Varese.

There are two commercial airports that serve Cutler Cay - Miami International Airport (MIA), which is fourteen miles away, and Fort Lauderdale Hollywood International Airport (FLL), which is 35 miles away.

Cutler Cay real estate activity on the Cutler Bay MLS during the past year (as of February 2026) reflects twenty eight homes changing hands, with an average asking price of $1,157,902 and an average selling price of $1,124,071. This represents a healthy list-to-sell price ratio of 97% and $215 per square foot. During this period, Cutler Cay homes for sale have taken an average of 128 days to sell.

In addition, there are numerous other communities in Cutler Bay to choose from, or you may browse all available Cutler Bay Real Estate, including some new construction opportunities. Homes for sale in Cutler Cay are selling quickly. Set up a new listing alert, and we will notify you immediately when a new waterfront home in Cutler Cay hits the market. You can also always contact your ZFC Real Estate agent, who would happily assist you further with all your South Florida real estate needs.

Cutler Cay Homes For Sale

$1.95 Million

MLS#AX-11899987

19512 Sw 79th Pl
Cutler Bay, FL 33157

5

4

3

5,951 SqFt

Water Front

0.213 Acres

115 Days

$1,299,000

MLS#AX-11883394

7408 Sw 189th St
Cutler Bay, FL 33157

5

4

2

4,294 SqFt

0.18 Acres

628 Days

Reduced

$1,280,000

$1,370,000

MLS#AX-11903639

7587 Sw 189th St
Cutler Bay, FL 33157

5

4

2

5,011 SqFt

0.292 Acres

109 Days

$1,275,000

MLS#AX-11820905

19383 Sw 79th Ave
Cutler Bay, FL 33157

5

4

3

5,951 SqFt

Water Front

0.223 Acres

247 Days

Reduced

$1,100,000

$1,350,000

MLS#AX-11731448

7796 Sw 193rd Ln
Cutler Bay, FL 33157

5

4

2

4,514 SqFt

0.19 Acres

449 Days

$1,050,000

MLS#AX-11904712

18704 Sw 76th Ct
Cutler Bay, FL 33157

5

5

2

4,514 SqFt

0.263 Acres

113 Days

Reduced

$999,777

$1,277,777

MLS#AX-11809953

7753 Sw 193rd St
Cutler Bay, FL 33157

5

4

2

5,039 SqFt

0.224 Acres

264 Days

Reduced

$995,000

$1,150,000

MLS#AX-11911584

19528 Sw 79th Pl
Cutler Bay, FL 33157

5

4

3

3,957 SqFt

Water Front

0.225 Acres

92 Days

8 Active Listings in Cutler Cay