Old Cutler Square

Old Cutler Square is a community of single family homes in Cutler Bay, Florida, with a range of options priced between $184,900 and $750,000. The smallest Old Cutler Square home in the community is a three bedroom two bathroom residence that is 1,870 square feet, and the largest of the Old Cutler Square homes has four beds and three baths and is a 2,798 square foot (2,658SF Under Air) residence.

Property management fees in Miami-Dade County vary depending on the community and sometimes vary between homes in the community. The current HOA fees for homes in Old Cutler Square range from $60 to $170. This fee includes common area maintenance. Please check the individual listing pages for the exact homeowners association fees for a particular Old Cutler Square home.

The Old Cutler Square HOA rules do allow homeowners to have pets with no restrictions imposed.

There are two commercial airports that serve Old Cutler Square - Miami International Airport (MIA), which is sixteen miles away, and Fort Lauderdale Hollywood International Airport (FLL), which is 37 miles away.

Old Cutler Square real estate activity on the Cutler Bay MLS during the past year (as of September 2025) reflects two homes changing hands, with an average asking price of $694,500 and an average selling price of $670,500. This represents a healthy list-to-sell price ratio of 97% and $285 per square foot. During this period, Old Cutler Square homes for sale have taken an average of 53 days to sell.

In addition, there are numerous other communities in Cutler Bay to choose from, or you may browse all available Cutler Bay Real Estate, including some new construction opportunities. Homes for sale in Old Cutler Square are selling quickly. Set up a new listing alert, and we will notify you immediately when a new home in Old Cutler Square hits the market. You can also always contact your ZFC Real Estate agent, who would happily assist you further with all your South Florida real estate needs.

Old Cutler Square Homes For Sale

SOLD 11/15/22

$585,000

MLS#AX-11265846

9712 Sw 213th Ter
Cutler Bay, FL 33189

4

2

2

2,022 SqFt

0.172 Acres

SOLD 07/19/13

$259,900

MLS#AX-1774838

9704 Sw 213 Te
Miami, FL 33189

4

3

2

2,658 SqFt

SOLD 08/01/13

$260,000

MLS#AX-1800137

21370 Sw 97 Ct
Cutler Bay, FL 33189

4

3

2

2,649 SqFt

SOLD 12/29/17

$349,900

MLS#AX-10362057

21350 Sw 97th Ct
Cutler Bay, FL 33189

3

2

2

2,144 SqFt

0.174 Acres

SOLD 07/05/17

$298,000

$305,000

MLS#AX-10213068

9709 Sw 213th Ter
Cutler Bay, FL 33189

3

3

1

1,870 SqFt

0.111 Acres

SOLD 09/17/14

$187,900

$209,900

MLS#AX-1962743

9725 Sw 213 Te
Cutler Bay, FL 33189

4

3

2

2,658 SqFt

SOLD 02/12/19

$339,900

MLS#AX-10586844

9705 Sw 213th Ter
Cutler Bay, FL 33189

3

3

2

2,124 SqFt

Water Front

0.114 Acres

SOLD 06/22/23

$649,900

$659,900

MLS#AX-11299647

21341 Sw 97th Ct
Cutler Bay, FL 33189

4

3

2

2,571 SqFt

Water Front

0.123 Acres

SOLD 06/28/21

$459,000

MLS#AX-11016789

21341 Sw 97th Ct
Cutler Bay, FL 33189

4

3

2

2,571 SqFt

Water Front

0.123 Acres

SOLD 01/23/14

$269,000

MLS#AX-1872623

21341 Sw 97 Ct
Cutler Bay, FL 33189

4

3

2

2,571 SqFt

Water Front

SOLD 12/09/19

$340,000

$350,000

MLS#AX-10750859

21320 Sw 97th Ave
Cutler Bay, FL 33189

4

3

2

2,207 SqFt

Water Front

0.131 Acres

SOLD 08/04/25

$639,000

MLS#AX-11804699

21320 Sw 97th Ave
Cutler Bay, FL 33189

4

3

2

2,647 SqFt

Water Front

0.123 Acres

SOLD 08/09/18

$375,000

MLS#AX-10477811

21321 Sw 97th Ct
Cutler Bay, FL 33189

4

4

2,798 SqFt

Water Front

0.121 Acres

SOLD 12/07/20

$425,000

MLS#AX-10931815

21250 Sw 97th Ct
Cutler Bay, FL 33189

3

3

2

2,012 SqFt

0.173 Acres

SOLD 07/31/15

$260,000

$305,000

MLS#AX-2123829

21260 Sw 97 Av
Cutler Bay, FL 33189

4

3

2

2,269 SqFt

Water Front

SOLD 12/14/18

$365,000

$375,000

MLS#AX-10513556

21240 Sw 97th Ave
Cutler Bay, FL 33189

4

3

2

2,658 SqFt

Water Front

0.13 Acres

SOLD 03/31/16

$302,100

$318,000

MLS#AX-2157375

21240 Sw 97 Av
Cutler Bay, FL 33189

4

3

2

2,658 SqFt

Water Front

SOLD 02/24/17

$378,000

MLS#AX-10170812

21240 Sw 97th Ave
Cutler Bay, FL 33189

4

3

2

2,658 SqFt

Water Front

0.13 Acres

SOLD 09/21/20

$435,000

MLS#AX-10792387

21230 Sw 97th Ct
Cutler Bay, FL 33189

4

3

2

2,649 SqFt

0.173 Acres

SOLD 11/17/16

$349,900

$384,900

MLS#AX-10136348

21230 Sw 97 Ct
Miami, FL 33189

4

3

2

2,649 SqFt

0.173 Acres

SOLD 10/18/24

$750,000

$779,000

MLS#AX-11628938

21241 Sw 97th Ct
Cutler Bay, FL 33189

4

3

2

2,059 SqFt

Water Front

0.118 Acres

SOLD 08/30/19

$359,900

$375,000

MLS#AX-10663390

21241 Sw 97th Ct
Cutler Bay, FL 33189

4

3

2

2,059 SqFt

0.118 Acres

SOLD 07/25/17

$325,000

MLS#AX-10274693

21241 Sw 97th Ct
Cutler Bay, FL 33189

4

3

2

2,059 SqFt

0.118 Acres

SOLD 06/21/22

$639,000

MLS#AX-11191509

21220 Sw 97th Ave
Cutler Bay, FL 33189

4

3

2

2,631 SqFt

Water Front

0.14 Acres

---

We do not have any properties available for sale in Old Cutler Square.

0 Active Listings in Old Cutler Square