Captains Bay

Captains Bay is a waterfront condominium building in Fort Myers Beach, Florida, with a range of options priced between $399,900 and $550,000. There are currently a total of 8 condos for sale in Captains Bay. The smallest Captains Bay condo presently available is a two bedroom two bathroom residence that is 811 square feet, and the largest of the Captains Bay condos currently on the market has three beds and two baths and is a 1,272 square foot (1,239SF Under Air) residence.

Pets are allowed in Captains Bay.

There are three commercial airports that serve Captains Bay - Page Field (FMY), which is twelve miles away; Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW), which is twelve miles away, and Punta Gorda (PGD), which is 35 miles away.

Captains Bay real estate activity on the Fort Myers Beach MLS during the past year (as of December 2025) reflects three condos changing hands, with an average asking price of $416,333 and an average selling price of $389,667. This represents a healthy list-to-sell price ratio of 94% and $284 per square foot. During this period, Captains Bay condos for sale have taken an average of 99 days to sell.

In addition, there are numerous other condo buildings in Fort Myers Beach to choose from, or you may browse all available Condos for sale in Fort Myers Beach. Condos for sale in Captains Bay are selling quickly. Set up a new listing alert, and we will notify you immediately when a new waterfront condo in Captains Bay hits the market. You can also always contact your ZFC Real Estate agent, who would happily assist you further with all your real estate needs on Florida's southwest coast.

Captains Bay Condos For Sale

Reduced

$550,000

$575,000

MLS#225026438

22796 Island Pines Way 111
Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931

2

2

811 Sq Ft

0.102 Acres

459 Days

$549,000

MLS#2025021865

22736 Island Pines Way 502
Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931

3

2

1

1,239 Sq Ft

Pool

0.1086 Acres

33 Days

$499,000

MLS#225082499

22712 Island Pines Way 501
Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931

2

2

1,272 Sq Ft

Water Front

0.1 Acres

22 Days

Reduced

$489,000

$519,000

MLS#224091024

22700 Island Pines Way 503
Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931

2

2

1,201 Sq Ft

0.1114 Acres

407 Days

Reduced

$475,000

$489,500

MLS#2025005566

22748 Island Pines Way 401
Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931

2

2

1,059 Sq Ft

Water Front

0.1098 Acres

318 Days

$464,999

MLS#225076921

22736 Island Pines Way S 201
Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931

2

2

1,073 Sq Ft

0.1086 Acres

61 Days

Reduced

$449,900

$465,000

MLS#225007503

22724 Island Pines Way 101
Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931

2

2

1,073 Sq Ft

Water Front

321 Days

Under Contract

$399,900

MLS#2025022235

22724 Island Pines Way 403
Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931

2

2

1,073 Sq Ft

Water Front

31 Days

8 Active Listings in Captains Bay