Bay Harbour Islamorada

Bay Harbour is a waterfront community of single family homes, condos, and townhomes in Islamorada, Florida, with a range of options priced between $450,000 and $3,550,000. There are currently a total of 9 homes for sale in Bay Harbour. The smallest Bay Harbour home presently available is a three bedroom two bathroom residence that is 2,015 square feet, and the largest of the Bay Harbour homes currently on the market has five beds and three baths and is a 4,722 square foot (2,907SF Under Air) residence.

Bay Harbour amenities include a clubhouse, swimming pool, spa / hot tub, a state-of-the-art fitness center, and billiards room. Sports facilities include tennis courts, and pickleball courts. Onsite dining venues consist of a picnic area, and a barbecue area.

Boating enthusiasts will love the fact that the community has boat facilities including a boat ramp, and a boat dock. There is also private beach access.

Pets are allowed in Bay Harbour. There is a limitation on pet size.

Bay Harbour real estate activity on the Islamorada MLS during the past year (as of October 2025) reflects eight homes changing hands, with an average asking price of $2,214,966 and an average selling price of $2,009,000. This represents a healthy list-to-sell price ratio of 91% and $517 per square foot. During this period, Bay Harbour homes for sale have taken an average of 124 days to sell.

In addition, there are numerous other communities in Islamorada to choose from, or you may browse all available Islamorada Real Estate, including some new construction opportunities. Homes for sale in Bay Harbour are selling quickly. Set up a new listing alert, and we will notify you immediately when a new waterfront home in Bay Harbour hits the market. You can also always contact your ZFC Real Estate agent, who would happily assist you further with all your Florida real estate needs.

Bay Harbour Homes For Sale

Reduced

$3,550,000

$3,800,000

MLS#AX-11760896

145 Venetian Drive
Islamorada, FL 33036

4

4

2

Water Front

211 Days

$3 Million

MLS#AX-11857499

122 Court Contessa
Islamorada, FL 33036

3

3

1

3,858 SqFt

Ocean Access

0.133 Acres

45 Days

Reduced

$2,775,000

$2,800,000

MLS#225049528

141 El Capitan Dr
Islamorada, FL 33036

4

3

3,650 SqFt

Pool

Water Front

0.15 Acres

134 Days

Reduced

$2,775,000

$2,800,000

MLS#AX-11807027

141 El Capitan Dr
Islamorada, FL 33036

4

3

3,650 SqFt

Water Front

0.149 Acres

134 Days

Reduced

$2,599,000

$2,700,000

MLS#225030328

189 Gulfview Dr
Islamorada, FL 33036

3

2

1

4,722 SqFt

Pool

Water Front

0.15 Acres

194 Days

Reduced

$2,599,000

$2,700,000

MLS#AX-11767222

189 Gulfview Dr
Islamorada, FL 33036

3

2

1

4,722 SqFt

Water Front

0.149 Acres

194 Days

Reduced

$1,650,000

$1,700,000

MLS#AX-11674250

121 Venetian Dr
Islamorada, FL 33036

3

2

1

2,791 SqFt

Water Front

0.161 Acres

359 Days

$1,225,000

MLS#AX-11833839

101 Gulfview Dr 116
Islamorada, FL 33036

3

3

1

2,026 Sq Ft

Ocean Access

541 Days

$450,000

MLS#AX-11844343

134 Nautilus Dr
Islamorada, FL 33036

5

4

3,577 SqFt

Ocean Access

0.161 Acres

75 Days

You may also be interested in Bay Harbour in Longboat Key.

9 Active Listings in Bay Harbour