Buttonwood Bay

Buttonwood Bay is a waterfront community of single family homes, condos, and townhomes in Key Largo, Florida, with a range of options priced between $324,814 and $825,000. The smallest Buttonwood Bay home in the community is a three bedroom two bathroom residence that is 1,405 square feet.

Property management fees in Monroe County vary depending on the community and sometimes vary between homes in the community. The current HOA fees for homes in Buttonwood Bay are $851 and $534 for a Buttonwood Bay condos and $597 for a townhome. This fee includes common area maintenance, grounds maintenance, building maintenance, roof repair and replacement, the community pool, and security. Also included is property insurance, water, trash removal, sewer, pest control, Cable TV & internet, parking, and recreation facilities. Please check the individual listing pages for the exact homeowners association fees for a particular Buttonwood Bay home.

Buttonwood Bay amenities include a clubhouse, swimming pool, spa / hot tub, a state-of-the-art fitness center, sauna, hobby room, vehicle wash area, and a library. Sports facilities include tennis courts, pickleball courts, and basketball court. Onsite dining venues consist of a community kitchen, picnic area, and a barbecue area.

Boating enthusiasts will love the fact that the community has boat facilities including a boat dock, and a community marina. There is also a playground, a waterfront pier, as well as private beach access.

The Buttonwood Bay HOA rules do allow homeowners to have pets although there are some restrictions. There is a limitation on pet size.

Buttonwood Bay real estate activity on the Key Largo MLS during the past year (as of September 2025) reflects four homes changing hands, with an average asking price of $1,006,000 and an average selling price of $947,500. This represents a healthy list-to-sell price ratio of 94% and $728 per square foot. During this period, Buttonwood Bay homes for sale have taken an average of 137 days to sell.

In addition, there are numerous other communities in Key Largo to choose from, or you may browse all available Key Largo Real Estate, including some new construction opportunities. Homes for sale in Buttonwood Bay are selling quickly. Set up a new listing alert, and we will notify you immediately when a new waterfront home in Buttonwood Bay hits the market. You can also always contact your ZFC Real Estate agent, who would happily assist you further with all your Florida real estate needs.

Buttonwood Bay Homes For Sale

SOLD 08/22/25

$1,300,000

MLS#AX-11813562

96000 Overseas Hwy X54 + 29' Slip
Key Largo, FL 33037

2

2

Water Front

SOLD 06/23/23

$899,000

$975,000

MLS#AX-11388521

96000 Overseas Hwy Ee33
Key Largo, FL 33037

2

2

1,278 Sq Ft

Bay Front

SOLD 06/06/24

$989,900

$995,900

MLS#AX-11535222

96000 N Oversea Highway W 43
Key Largo, FL 33037

2

2

1,246 Sq Ft

Water Front

SOLD 09/18/19

$825,000

$899,000

MLS#AX-10711229

96000 Overseas Hwy
Other City - Keys/islands/caribbean, FL 33037

3

2

2

Bay Front

SOLD 08/12/19

$624,000

MLS#AX-10709864

96000 Overseas Hwy G-4
Other City - Keys/islands/caribbean, FL 33037

2

3

1,221 Sq Ft

Water Front

SOLD 10/26/18

$499,000

$639,000

MLS#AX-10455365

96000 Overseas Hwy Dd-1
Other City - Keys/islands/caribbean, FL 33037

2

3

1,223 Sq Ft

Water Front

SOLD 12/27/13

$429,900

MLS#AX-1864588

96000 Overseas Hwy D 1
Other City - Keys/islands/caribbean, FL 33037

2

2

Ocean Access

SOLD 03/30/12

$324,814

MLS#AX-1581760

96000 Overseas Hwy Dd8
Other City - Keys/islands/caribbean, FL 33037

2

3

1,405 Sq Ft

Water Front

SOLD 08/25/21

$949,000

MLS#AX-11068613

96000 Overseas Hwy W4
Key Largo, FL 33037

2

2

1,278 Sq Ft

Ocean Access

SOLD 07/17/20

$829,000

MLS#AX-10877156

96000 Overseas Highway M2
Key Largo, FL 33037

2

3

Bay Front

SOLD 10/12/23

$1,199,000

MLS#AX-11437212

96000 Overseas Hwy N8
Key Largo, FL 33037

2

2

1,056 Sq Ft

Bay Front

SOLD 09/05/24

$824,900

$879,900

MLS#AX-11584073

96000 Overseas Hwy P4
Key Largo, FL 33037

2

2

1,229 SqFt

Water Front

SOLD 11/18/24

$939,000

$1,150,000

MLS#AX-11588557

96000 Overseas Highway A9
Key Largo, FL 33037

2

3

1,238 SqFt

Water Front

SOLD 08/16/24

$1,240,000

$1,340,000

MLS#AX-11580313

96000 Overseas Hwy W4+36ftslip
Key Largo, FL 33037

2

2

1,278 Sq Ft

Bay Front

SOLD 10/11/24

$945,000

$1,099,900

MLS#AX-11623615

96000 Overseas Hwy A3
Key Largo, FL 33037

2

3

1,238 Sq Ft

Water Front

SOLD 04/04/25

$999,000

$1,050,000

MLS#AX-11635507

96000 Overseas Hwy C4
Key Largo, FL 33037

2

3

1,238 Sq Ft

Water Front

SOLD 08/20/25

$985,000

$1,090,000

MLS#AX-11774282

96000 Overseas Hwy T1
Key Largo, FL 33037

2

3

1,454 SqFt

Water Front

SOLD 08/15/25

$1,095,000

MLS#AX-11728148

96000 Overseas Hwy X23+36ftslip
Key Largo, FL 33037

2

2

1,278 Sq Ft

Water Front

---

We do not have any properties available for sale in Buttonwood Bay.

0 Active Listings in Buttonwood Bay