Homes Sold in Buttonwood Bay

Listed here are all the documented MLS sales of homes in Buttonwood Bay in Key Largo as recently as 08/22/2025 and as far back as 03/30/2012. If you are looking for the currently available inventory see Homes For Sale in Buttonwood Bay or you may browse all available Key Largo Real Estate. Private sales not recorded in the MLS are not reflected here. Please contact us for a more complete update on sales activity in Buttonwood Bay

Average List Price$883,140

Average Sold Price$831,611

List/Sell Ratio94%

Average Size1,273 Square Feet

Average Days On Market75

Average Price Per Square Foot$1,176

Note: Because our historical sales data goes back as far as 10 years or more, keep in mind the statistical figures above reflect the averages of this entire period of time. Current market conditions can vary greatly from these averages.

Notify me when new listings become available in Buttonwood Bay

Your Home's Market Value

Enter Your Address for a free, professional price analysis of your home.

Buttonwood Bay Closed Sales

MLS Number List Price Sale Price Bed Bth Cars Size Location Sale Date

A11813562 $1,300,000 $Log in to view 2 2/ 0 0SF 96000 Overseas Hwy X54 + 29' Slip 08/22/2025

A11774282 $985,000 $Log in to view 2 2/1 0 1,454SF 96000 Overseas Hwy T1 08/20/2025

A11728148 $1,095,000 $Log in to view 2 2/0 0 1,278SF 96000 Overseas Hwy X23+36ftslip 08/15/2025

A11635507 $999,000 $Log in to view 2 2/1 0 1,238SF 96000 Overseas Hwy C4 04/04/2025

A11588557 $939,000 $Log in to view 2 2/1 0 0SF 96000 Overseas Highway A9 11/18/2024

A11623615 $945,000 $Log in to view 2 2/1 0 1,238SF 96000 Overseas Hwy A3 10/11/2024

A11584073 $824,900 $Log in to view 2 1/1 0 1,229SF 96000 Overseas Hwy P4 09/05/2024

A11580313 $1,240,000 $Log in to view 2 2/0 0 1,278SF 96000 Overseas Hwy W4+36ftslip 08/16/2024

A11535222 $989,900 $Log in to view 2 2/ 0 0SF 96000 N Oversea Highway W 43 06/06/2024

A11437212 $1,199,000 $Log in to view 2 1/1 0 1,056SF 96000 Overseas Hwy N8 10/12/2023

A11388521 $899,000 $Log in to view 2 2/0 0 1,278SF 96000 Overseas Hwy Ee33 06/23/2023

A11068613 $949,000 $Log in to view 2 2/0 0 1,278SF 96000 Overseas Hwy W4 08/25/2021

A10877156 $829,000 $Log in to view 2 3/ 0 0SF 96000 Overseas Highway M2 07/17/2020

A10711229 $825,000 $Log in to view 3 2/ 2 0SF 96000 Overseas Hwy 09/18/2019

A10709864 $624,000 $Log in to view 2 2/1 0 0SF 96000 Overseas Hwy G-4 08/12/2019

A10455365 $499,000 $Log in to view 2 2/1 0 0SF 96000 Overseas Hwy Dd-1 10/26/2018

A1864588 $429,900 $Log in to view 2 1/1 0 0SF 96000 Overseas Hwy D 1 12/27/2013

A1581760 $324,814 $Log in to view 2 2/1 0 1,405SF 96000 Overseas Hwy Dd8 03/30/2012

The data relating to homes for sale or lease or other real estate for sale or for rent on the ZFC website comes in part from a cooperative data exchange program of the MLS in which this Broker participates. The real estate displayed may not be all of the homes in the database, or all of the properties listed with Brokers participating in the cooperative data exchange program. Homes for sale that are listed by Brokers other than this Broker are marked with either the listing Broker's name or the MLS name or a logo provided by the MLS and the details page about such properties includes the name of the listing Brokers. Information provided is thought to be reliable but is not guaranteed to be accurate; you are advised to verify facts that are important to you. No warranties, expressed or implied, are provided for the data herein, or for their use or interpretation by the user. ZFC, the Florida Association of Realtors and its cooperating Multiple Listing Services do not create, control or review the property data displayed herein and take no responsibility for the content of such records. Federal law including the fair housing act prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin in the sale, rental or financing of housing. IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.