Sheffield Lake Mary

Sheffield is a community of single family homes in Lake Mary, Florida, with a range of options priced between $199,500 and $669,500. The smallest Sheffield home in the community is a three bedroom two bathroom residence that is 2,078 square feet (1,873SF Under Air living space), and the largest of the Sheffield homes has four beds and three baths and is a 3,890 square foot (3,188SF Under Air) residence.

Property management fees in Seminole County vary depending on the community and sometimes vary between homes in the community. The current HOA fees for homes in Sheffield range from $100 to $710. This fee includes. Please check the individual listing pages for the exact homeowners association fees for a particular Sheffield home.

The Sheffield HOA rules do allow homeowners to have pets. Dogs and cats are allowed.

There are four commercial airports that serve Sheffield - Orlando Sanford International (SFB), which is eight miles away; Orlando Executive (ORL), which is thirteen miles away; Orlando International (MCO), which is twenty one miles away, and Kissimmee Gateway (ISM), which is 31 miles away from Sheffield.

Sheffield real estate activity on the Lake Mary MLS during the past year (as of October 2025) reflects three homes changing hands, with an average asking price of $551,500 and an average selling price of $540,000. This represents a healthy list-to-sell price ratio of 98% and $189 per square foot. During this period, Sheffield homes for sale have taken an average of 91 days to sell.

In addition, there are numerous other communities in Lake Mary to choose from, or you may browse all available Lake Mary Real Estate, including some new construction opportunities. Homes for sale in Sheffield are selling quickly. Set up a new listing alert, and we will notify you immediately when a new home in Sheffield hits the market. You can also always contact your ZFC Real Estate agent, who would happily assist you further with all your Florida real estate needs.

Sheffield Homes For Sale

SOLD 07/22/22

$399,900

MLS#MFRO6038768

855 Silverado Ct
Lake Mary, FL 32746

3

2

2

2,569 SqFt

0.33 Acres

SOLD 07/26/24

$497,500

MLS#MFRO6208060

855 Silverado Ct
Lake Mary, FL 32746

3

2

2

2,569 SqFt

0.29 Acres

SOLD 10/29/21

$449,900

MLS#MFRO5971315

859 Silverado Ct
Lake Mary, FL 32746

4

3

2

2,811 SqFt

Pool

0.21 Acres

SOLD 03/22/23

$480,000

$520,000

MLS#MFRO6034685

808 Silversmith Cir
Lake Mary, FL 32746

4

3

2

2,090 SqFt

Pool

0.25 Acres

SOLD 09/19/14

$275,000

MLS#MFRO5312691

792 Silversmith Cir
Lake Mary, FL 32746

4

3

2

2,809 SqFt

Pool

0.41 Acres

SOLD 06/22/23

$499,000

MLS#MFRO6112060

788 Silversmith Cir
Lake Mary, FL 32746

4

3

2

2,846 SqFt

Pool

0.44 Acres

SOLD 03/09/16

$240,000

MLS#MFRS4825630

824 Silversmith Cir
Lake Mary, FL 32746

4

3

2

2,857 SqFt

Pool

0.25 Acres

SOLD 12/30/21

$424,900

$433,900

MLS#MFRO5977797

866 Silverado Ct
Lake Mary, FL 32746

4

2

2

3,071 SqFt

0.15 Acres

SOLD 07/29/16

$315,000

$322,500

MLS#MFRO5425282

797 Silversmith Cir
Lake Mary, FL 32746

4

3

2

2,896 SqFt

Pool

0.2 Acres

SOLD 07/28/17

$289,900

$299,900

MLS#MFRO5503676

825 Silversmith Cir
Lake Mary, FL 32746

4

3

2

2,976 SqFt

Pool

0.17 Acres

SOLD 12/02/24

$485,000

MLS#MFRO6249011

801 Silversmith Cir
Lake Mary, FL 32746

4

3

2

2,896 SqFt

Pool

0.16 Acres

SOLD 08/03/15

$219,900

MLS#MFRO5376864

829 Silversmith Cir
Lake Mary, FL 32746

3

2

2

2,569 SqFt

Pool

0.2 Acres

SOLD 10/14/16

$275,000

$279,000

MLS#MFRO5454893

936 Silverton Loop
Lake Mary, FL 32746

3

2

2

2,849 SqFt

Pool

0.16 Acres

SOLD 01/22/24

$550,000

MLS#MFRO6163251

936 Silverton Loop
Lake Mary, FL 32746

3

2

2

2,849 SqFt

Pool

0.16 Acres

SOLD 08/28/13

$269,000

MLS#MFRO5170433

769 Silversmith Cir
Lake Mary, FL 32746

4

3

2

2,896 SqFt

0.16 Acres

SOLD 06/08/22

$459,000

MLS#MFRO6021639

856 Silversmith Cir
Lake Mary, FL 32746

4

2

2

2,882 SqFt

0.2 Acres

SOLD 06/05/15

$269,900

$274,900

MLS#MFRO5316052

913 Stillwell Ln
Lake Mary, FL 32746

4

3

2

2,944 SqFt

Pool

0.17 Acres

SOLD 10/10/13

$215,000

MLS#MFRS4710192

760 Silversmith Cir
Lake Mary, FL 32746

4

3

2

2,896 SqFt

Pool

0.19 Acres

SOLD 03/11/22

$430,000

MLS#MFRO6002993

910 Stillwell Ln
Lake Mary, FL 32746

4

3

2

3,132 SqFt

0.23 Acres

SOLD 07/31/13

$250,000

MLS#MFRO5166607

910 Stillwell Ln
Lake Mary, FL 32746

4

3

2

3,132 SqFt

0.23 Acres

SOLD 08/11/22

$445,000

$476,500

MLS#MFRO6018266

935 Stillwell Ct
Lake Mary, FL 32746

4

3

2

2,809 SqFt

0.15 Acres

SOLD 03/23/17

$319,900

MLS#MFRO5492536

972 Silverton Loop
Lake Mary, FL 32746

4

3

2

2,809 SqFt

Pool

0.17 Acres

SOLD 07/09/13

$250,000

MLS#MFRO5160926

972 Silverton Loop
Lake Mary, FL 32746

4

3

2

2,809 SqFt

Pool

0.17 Acres

SOLD 06/30/17

$289,000

MLS#MFRO5512074

976 Silverton Loop
Lake Mary, FL 32746

4

3

2

2,809 SqFt

Pool

0.18 Acres

---

We do not have any properties available for sale in Sheffield.

You may also be interested in Sheffield in Lakeland or Sheffield in Tampa.

0 Active Listings in Sheffield