Homes Sold in Casey Key
Average List Price$3,417,448
Average Sold Price$3,046,241
List/Sell Ratio89%
Average Size5,428 Square Feet
Average Days On Market203
Average Price Per Square Foot$602
Note: Because our historical sales data goes back as far as 10 years or more, keep in mind the statistical figures above reflect the averages of this entire period of time. Current market conditions can vary greatly from these averages.
Notify me when new listings become available in Casey Key
Your Home's Market Value
Enter Your Address for a free, professional price analysis of your home.
Casey Key Closed Sales
MLS Number
List Price
Sale Price
Bed
Bth
Cars
Size
Location
Sale Date
MFRA4638278
$2,290,000
$Log in to view
2
1/0
952SF
325 Casey Key Rd
10/03/2025
MFRA4659910
$6,550,000
$Log in to view
5
4/1
4
11,189SF
1822 Casey Key Rd
10/01/2025
MFRN6138837
$6,700,000
$Log in to view
4
3/1
2
6,139SF
3516 Casey Key Rd
08/20/2025
MFRN6134765
$3,250,000
$Log in to view
4
3/1
1
3,515SF
5 N Casey Key Rd
08/15/2025
MFRA4630341
$4,580,000
$Log in to view
4
4/1
2
5,609SF
681 Casey Key Rd
08/15/2025
MFRA4643566
$4,000,000
$Log in to view
4
4/2
4
11,143SF
3909 Casey Key Rd
07/18/2025
MFRA4652828
$375,000
$Log in to view
0
1/0
245SF
105 Casey Key Rd #20
06/18/2025
MFRA4598712
$3,150,000
$Log in to view
2
2/0
2
2,793SF
406 S Casey Key Rd
06/10/2025
MFRA4648365
$3,300,000
$Log in to view
3
3/1
4
5,756SF
924 Casey Cove Dr
05/15/2025
MFRA4634954
$950,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
3,337SF
3712 Sandspur Ln
05/14/2025
MFRA4634222
$1,780,000
$Log in to view
2
2/1
2
2,859SF
411 S Casey Key Rd
05/09/2025
MFRA4640352
$2,777,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
2
3,416SF
2812 Casey Key Rd
05/05/2025
MFRA4649959
$2,900,000
$Log in to view
2
2/0
1,186SF
2410 Casey Key Rd
04/23/2025
MFRN6136051
$3,200,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
2
4,739SF
1608 Casey Key Rd
04/03/2025
MFRA4631842
$10,750,000
$Log in to view
5
5/2
2
10,426SF
1776 Casey Key Rd
03/19/2025
MFRA4632619
$2,900,000
$Log in to view
3
2/1
2
3,323SF
4029 Casey Key Rd
02/24/2025
MFRA4628497
$325,000
$Log in to view
1
1/0
405SF
105 Casey Key Rd #47
12/16/2024
MFRN6131838
$3,850,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
1
3,188SF
1604 Casey Key Rd
07/31/2024
MFRA4562025
$5,000,000
$Log in to view
4
4/2
3
11,690SF
4019 Casey Key Rd
07/23/2024
MFRN6128311
$1,800,000
$Log in to view
2
2/0
1
2,034SF
922 Casey Cove Dr
05/30/2024
MFRA4570438
$3,750,000
$Log in to view
5
4/0
3
6,998SF
3760 Casey Key Rd
05/15/2024
MFRA4574833
$1,800,000
$Log in to view
3
2/1
2
5,319SF
624 S Casey Key Rd
05/10/2024
MFRN6130747
$3,250,000
$Log in to view
4
4/0
2
4,343SF
916 Casey Cove Dr
04/30/2024
MFRN6129901
$5,975,000
$Log in to view
5
6/1
3
10,382SF
2006 Casey Key Rd
04/12/2024
MFRA4574918
$5,200,000
$Log in to view
3
4/1
2
8,810SF
1704 Casey Key Rd
04/10/2024
MFRA4580658
$6,500,000
$Log in to view
4
3/0
3
5,110SF
2509 Casey Key Rd
04/04/2024
MFRA4555150
$2,300,000
$Log in to view
3
2/1
2
5,715SF
2800 Casey Key Rd
12/15/2023
MFRA4572549
$10,250,000
$Log in to view
4
4/2
3
6,328SF
3699 Casey Key Rd
10/26/2023
MFRA4580409
$895,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
1,170SF
105 Casey Key Rd #34
10/06/2023
MFRA4559656
$7,500,000
$Log in to view
6
5/2
4
12,292SF
2305 Casey Key Rd
09/25/2023
MFRA4533327
$15,000,000
$Log in to view
6
7/1
8
20,154SF
1312 Casey Key Rd
08/25/2023
MFRA4546715
$11,500,000
$Log in to view
6
5/1
3
0SF
615-621 Casey Key Rd
08/03/2023
MFRA4569109
$2,995,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
3,242SF
3727 Sandspur Ln
06/15/2023
MFRA4567432
$3,200,000
$Log in to view
2
2/0
1
1,755SF
3216 Casey Key Rd
05/31/2023
MFRA4534806
$2,750,000
$Log in to view
3
3/1
1
2,691SF
4004 Casey Key Rd
05/19/2023
MFRA4562902
$2,695,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
2,802SF
3858 Casey Key
05/15/2023
MFRA4542528
$2,800,000
$Log in to view
4
3/1
2
0SF
3214 Casey Key Rd
04/27/2023
MFRA4559876
$7,690,000
$Log in to view
9
6/0
6,200SF
408 S Casey Key Rd #1to6
04/19/2023
MFRA4556483
$3,000,000
$Log in to view
2
3/0
2
3,587SF
1208 Casey Key Rd
03/28/2023
MFRN6125025
$3,500,000
$Log in to view
2
2/0
1
3,188SF
1604 Casey Key Rd
03/24/2023
MFRN6124573
$2,250,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
2,925SF
121 Casey Key Rd
03/16/2023
MFRJ955147
$8,500,000
$Log in to view
4
4/2
10
11,391SF
1906 Casey Key Rd
11/30/2022
MFRA4548688
$1,950,000
$Log in to view
3
2/1
3,307SF
1400 Casey Key Rd
11/17/2022
MFRA4530819
$4,695,000
$Log in to view
6
4/1
2
6,144SF
412 S Casey Key
10/13/2022
MFRA4537866
$6,499,000
$Log in to view
4
5/0
3
7,828SF
3752 Casey Key Rd
10/05/2022
MFRA4537154
$4,999,000
$Log in to view
4
3/1
2
5,189SF
521 Casey Key Rd
07/28/2022
MFRA4537168
$3,000,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
3,279SF
2816 Casey Key Rd
06/15/2022
MFRA4527233
$4,799,999
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
4,216SF
513 Casey Key Rd
05/18/2022
MFRJ948289
$3,500,000
$Log in to view
2
2/0
0SF
421 Casey Key Rd
05/11/2022
MFRA4522516
$5,995,000
$Log in to view
4
4/0
5
5,432SF
503 Casey Key Rd
05/04/2022
MFRA4531175
$895,000
$Log in to view
2
1/1
1,363SF
616 S Casey Key Rd
04/29/2022
MFRN6119210
$10,950,000
$Log in to view
5
6/2
4
0SF
1144 Sea Grape Point Rd
04/21/2022
MFRA4518386
$6,900,000
$Log in to view
4
5/1
3
10,722SF
144 N Casey Key Rd
04/20/2022
222088789
$4,000,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
1
5,434SF
1300 Casey Key Rd
04/20/2022
MFRA4510219
$2,800,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
2
3,416SF
2812 Casey Key Rd
03/30/2022
MFRA4513580
$3,495,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
5,434SF
1300 Casey Key Rd
01/18/2022
MFRA4505251
$3,900,000
$Log in to view
6
5/2
3
6,928SF
430 Casey Key Rd
01/10/2022
MFRA4521307
$3,000,000
$Log in to view
2
3/0
2
4,308SF
941 Casey Key Rd
01/04/2022
MFRN6117195
$1,875,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
3
3,319SF
3804 Cutlass Bayou Ln
12/30/2021
MFRN6117196
$3,100,000
$Log in to view
4
3/1
2
3,300SF
707 Casey Key Rd
12/20/2021
MFRA4514140
$1,495,000
$Log in to view
4
2/2
3,222SF
3708 Sandspur Ln
11/12/2021
MFRA4509445
$2,225,000
$Log in to view
2
3/0
2
3,481SF
1208 Casey Key Rd
11/10/2021
MFRA4512242
$4,995,000
$Log in to view
4
3/0
4,118SF
1112 N Casey Key Rd
10/29/2021
MFRA4501072
$1,649,000
$Log in to view
3
4/0
2
5,624SF
3604 Casey Key Rd Rd
10/20/2021
MFRA4515450
$729,900
$Log in to view
3
2/1
4
4,408SF
4028 Casey Key Rd
10/18/2021
MFRA4487481
$3,290,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
0SF
4001 Casey Key Rd
06/01/2021
MFRA4425609
$2,589,900
$Log in to view
4
3/0
2
3,010SF
4005 Casey Key Rd
05/21/2021
MFRA4493576
$7,984,000
$Log in to view
4
5/1
12
0SF
13 N Casey Key Rd
04/29/2021
MFRN6112510
$5,490,000
$Log in to view
6
6/3
5
13,739SF
3860 Casey Key Rd
04/28/2021
MFRA4491376
$19,900,000
$Log in to view
5
5/2
10
19,905SF
1900 Casey Key Rd
04/28/2021
MFRA4492012
$6,975,000
$Log in to view
5
6/1
5
8,615SF
2905 Casey Key Rd
04/22/2021
MFRA4472437
$4,200,000
$Log in to view
5
5/1
4
8,295SF
4009 Casey Key Rd
04/13/2021
MFRA4483860
$1,690,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
0SF
3858 Casey Key Rd
04/08/2021
MFRA4474963
$7,995,000
$Log in to view
4
4/1
5
13,528SF
612 S Casey Key Rd
12/28/2020
MFRN6108928
$848,000
$Log in to view
2
2/0
0SF
113 Casey Key Rd #6
12/24/2020
MFRA4463557
$6,200,000
$Log in to view
4
5/1
3
12,708SF
602 S Casey Key Rd
07/28/2020
MFRN6108566
$2,499,000
$Log in to view
3
3/1
4
4,603SF
508 S Casey Key Rd
05/22/2020
MFRA4425965
$2,800,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
2
0SF
3619 Casey Key Rd
04/29/2019
MFRN5915098
$2,400,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
2
3,883SF
3509 Casey Key Rd
03/25/2019
MFRA4413495
$3,895,000
$Log in to view
4
3/0
3
5,110SF
2509 Casey Key Rd
11/30/2018
MFRA4181732
$899,500
$Log in to view
3
4/0
2
5,624SF
3604 Casey Key Rd
08/20/2018
MFRA4189751
$7,995,000
$Log in to view
3
4/3
5
16,761SF
1492 Casey Key Rd
06/18/2018
MFRA4177003
$525,000
$Log in to view
1
1/0
737SF
427 Casey Key Rd #4
03/16/2018
MFRA4176315
$1,995,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
2
2,713SF
3913 Casey Key Rd
10/12/2017
MFRA4173167
$469,000
$Log in to view
1
1/0
652SF
113 Casey Key Rd #7
06/23/2017
MFRA4168703
$1,550,000
$Log in to view
4
4/1
2
4,946SF
917 Key Way
03/31/2017
MFRA4167737
$3,795,000
$Log in to view
4
4/0
4
6,348SF
2823 Casey Key Rd
03/08/2017
MFRA4172452
$3,300,000
$Log in to view
3
3/1
2
4,978SF
1908 Casey Key Rd
02/02/2017
MFRA4169907
$3,980,000
$Log in to view
3
3/1
3
5,694SF
2901 Casey Key Rd
01/13/2017
MFRA4146441
$990,000
$Log in to view
2
2/0
1,050SF
1628 Casey Key Rd
10/31/2016
MFRA4160902
$5,500,000
$Log in to view
4
6/1
4
11,984SF
2411 & 2413 Casey Key Rd
08/01/2016
MFRA4141293
$839,900
$Log in to view
3
3/0
2
3,581SF
921 Key Way
07/27/2016
MFRU7767792
$1,250,000
$Log in to view
6
4/1
6,144SF
412 S Casey Key Rd
05/05/2016
MFRA4135572
$999,989
$Log in to view
3
2/1
2
5,202SF
624 S Casey Key Rd
04/21/2016
MFRA4114185
$2,100,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
2
5,028SF
1216 Casey Key Rd
12/11/2015
MFRA4134641
$449,500
$Log in to view
1
1/0
652SF
113 Casey Key Rd #7
11/30/2015
MFRN5783796
$939,900
$Log in to view
4
3/1
1
5,447SF
505 S Casey Key Rd
11/12/2015
MFRA4112331
$3,125,000
$Log in to view
5
4/1
3
6,083SF
904 Casey Cove Dr
09/30/2015
MFRA3999236
$5,895,000
$Log in to view
4
6/1
2
8,799SF
3601 Casey Key Rd
07/02/2015
A1938298
$3,390,000
$Log in to view
5
5/1
2
5,515SF
927 Casey Cove
05/29/2015
The data relating to homes for sale or lease or other real estate for sale or for rent on the ZFC website comes in part from a cooperative data exchange program of the MLS in which this Broker participates. The real estate displayed may not be all of the homes in the database, or all of the properties listed with Brokers participating in the cooperative data exchange program. Homes for sale that are listed by Brokers other than this Broker are marked with either the listing Broker's name or the MLS name or a logo provided by the MLS and the details page about such properties includes the name of the listing Brokers. Information provided is thought to be reliable but is not guaranteed to be accurate; you are advised to verify facts that are important to you. No warranties, expressed or implied, are provided for the data herein, or for their use or interpretation by the user. ZFC, the Florida Association of Realtors and its cooperating Multiple Listing Services do not create, control or review the property data displayed herein and take no responsibility for the content of such records. Federal law including the fair housing act prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin in the sale, rental or financing of housing. IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
