Homes Sold in Sanibel Bayous
Average List Price$985,523
Average Sold Price$934,402
List/Sell Ratio95%
Average Size5,088 Square Feet
Average Days On Market188
Average Price Per Square Foot$184
Note: Because our historical sales data goes back as far as 10 years or more, keep in mind the statistical figures above reflect the averages of this entire period of time. Current market conditions can vary greatly from these averages.
Notify me when new listings become available in Sanibel Bayous
Your Home's Market Value
Enter Your Address for a free, professional price analysis of your home.
Sanibel Bayous Closed Sales
MLS Number
List Price
Sale Price
Bed
Bth
Cars
Size
Location
Sale Date
2025003683
$997,555
$Log in to view
3
3/0
4
3,361SF
5300 Umbrella Pool Rd
09/04/2025
225020242
$1,579,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
3,706SF
1817 Long Point Ln
05/15/2025
225003978
$699,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
2,584SF
4596 Buck Key Rd
05/06/2025
224000166
$1,875,000
$Log in to view
4
4/1
2
10,773SF
5387 Shearwater Dr
12/06/2024
224037616
$1,384,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
4,886SF
4573 Bowen Bayou Rd
08/07/2024
224021143
$995,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
2,829SF
5305 Ladyfinger Lake Rd
07/26/2024
224015109
$1,387,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
3
7,259SF
5414 Osprey Ct
07/12/2024
224011850
$2,250,000
$Log in to view
3
3/1
2
4,074SF
5436 Shearwater Dr
04/08/2024
224004875
$979,000
$Log in to view
3
2/1
3
4,728SF
5303 Umbrella Pool Rd
04/05/2024
223086670
$699,900
$Log in to view
2
1/0
0
1,522SF
2066 Wild Lime Dr
04/04/2024
223079210
$1,495,000
$Log in to view
3
2/1
2
4,436SF
5298 Umbrella Pool Rd
03/28/2024
223088170
$985,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
0
4,000SF
2058 Wild Lime Dr
03/07/2024
223019977
$825,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
4,562SF
2042 Wild Lime Dr
11/10/2023
223068238
$925,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
4,861SF
1990 My Tern Ct
11/05/2023
222083526
$1,150,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
4,000SF
4565 Bowen Bayou Rd
06/26/2023
223009780
$1,379,000
$Log in to view
3
2/1
2
5,549SF
5294 Umbrella Pool Rd
06/09/2023
223007042
$999,999
$Log in to view
3
2/1
3
6,645SF
5410 Osprey Ct
06/06/2023
222089961
$799,999
$Log in to view
3
2/1
0
5,472SF
1834 Long Point Ln
03/22/2023
223009605
$2,495,000
$Log in to view
3
3/1
2
8,256SF
5395 Shearwater Dr
03/16/2023
222013069
$2,400,000
$Log in to view
4
3/1
2
8,490SF
5435 Osprey Ct
12/15/2022
222035736
$1,100,000
$Log in to view
4
4/0
3
6,658SF
2010 Wild Lime Dr
07/08/2022
222031503
$1,299,900
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
4,100SF
1985 Wild Lime Dr
06/21/2022
222016065
$968,500
$Log in to view
3
3/0
2
4,889SF
5307 Ladyfinger Lake Rd
05/11/2022
222004099
$1,350,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
6,798SF
4563 Brainard Bayou Rd
03/30/2022
222009024
$829,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
2,402SF
4560 Brainard Bayou
03/30/2022
222011293
$850,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
1
3,684SF
5289 Ladyfinger Lake Rd
03/18/2022
221086244
$2,495,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
1
6,909SF
5415 Osprey Ct
02/22/2022
222006336
$1,725,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
6,619SF
4636 Bowen Bayou Rd
02/15/2022
221083748
$1,095,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
2
5,862SF
1943 Sanibel Bayou Rd
01/20/2022
221071881
$996,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
0
3,570SF
4619 Bowen Bayou Rd
12/03/2021
221077175
$1,399,000
$Log in to view
4
3/1
2
6,774SF
5418 Osprey Ct
12/01/2021
221066777
$995,000
$Log in to view
3
2/1
2
4,436SF
5298 Umbrella Pool Rd
11/24/2021
221054573
$779,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
2
4,620SF
5308 Ladyfinger Lake Rd
11/19/2021
221048904
$2,149,000
$Log in to view
4
3/0
2
8,186SF
5379 Shearwater Dr
10/07/2021
221037140
$819,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
0
2,481SF
4506 Bowen Bayou Rd
09/20/2021
221044409
$999,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
5,594SF
5268 Ladyfinger Lake Rd
09/15/2021
221037234
$1,148,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
2
4,890SF
5431 Shearwater Dr
08/12/2021
221035264
$979,900
$Log in to view
3
2/1
2
5,583SF
4516 Bowen Bayou Rd
07/29/2021
221026414
$729,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
0
4,034SF
4505 Bowen Bayou Rd
07/20/2021
221025634
$795,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
3,577SF
2098 Wild Lime Dr
06/02/2021
221011752
$800,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
4,524SF
4648 Buck Key Rd
05/28/2021
221014082
$1,098,000
$Log in to view
3
2/1
2
4,964SF
1983 My Tern Ct
05/24/2021
221027513
$1,245,000
$Log in to view
3
2/1
4
4,931SF
5423 Shearwater Dr
05/17/2021
221015585
$999,000
$Log in to view
3
2/1
2
4,809SF
5424 Shearwater Dr
05/14/2021
220079206
$759,000
$Log in to view
4
4/0
3
6,658SF
2010 Wild Lime Dr
04/30/2021
221005753
$570,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
2
4,727SF
2015 Wild Lime Dr
04/23/2021
221014477
$689,000
$Log in to view
3
2/1
2
4,728SF
5303 Umbrella Pool Rd
04/12/2021
221006789
$780,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
4
5,597SF
1985 Sanibel Bayou Rd
04/07/2021
220039157
$1,644,000
$Log in to view
4
3/0
2
9,472SF
5439 Osprey Ct
03/31/2021
220079532
$1,795,000
$Log in to view
3
3/1
3
7,279SF
5391 Shearwater Dr
02/01/2021
220013744
$469,900
$Log in to view
2
2/0
1
1,374SF
4606 Brainard Bayou Rd
09/30/2020
219073193
$799,000
$Log in to view
3
2/1
3
4,811SF
5422 Shearwater Dr
09/09/2020
219077146
$770,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
0
5,646SF
5304 Umbrella Pool Rd
09/04/2020
220021765
$1,095,000
$Log in to view
3
3/1
3
7,142SF
5419 Osprey Ct
08/14/2020
219064639
$574,900
$Log in to view
4
3/0
2
4,426SF
1973 Wild Lime Dr
07/31/2020
219080299
$599,000
$Log in to view
3
2/1
2
3,369SF
2065 Wild Lime Dr
06/22/2020
219071573
$679,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
3
4,884SF
5303 Ladyfinger Lake Rd
04/15/2020
219070254
$595,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
3,869SF
4619 Brainard Bayou Rd
02/28/2020
219064033
$975,000
$Log in to view
4
3/0
3
7,788SF
5402 Osprey Ct
02/07/2020
218071051
$999,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
6,087SF
5411 Osprey Ct
05/16/2019
216065015
$549,899
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
3,080SF
2074 Wild Lime Dr
05/01/2019
219015510
$595,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
4,582SF
5306 Ladyfinger Lake Rd
04/24/2019
217069866
$749,000
$Log in to view
4
3/0
1
4,961SF
5306 Umbrella Pool Rd
04/18/2019
219004853
$1,595,000
$Log in to view
4
3/0
2
3,818SF
5407 Osprey Court
03/01/2019
218077473
$789,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
5,034SF
5280 Ladyfinger Lake Rd
02/26/2019
218042617
$479,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
0
4,273SF
4542 Bowen Bayou Rd
10/23/2018
218006749
$749,000
$Log in to view
3
2/1
3
6,645SF
5410 Osprey Ct
08/30/2018
218034113
$599,900
$Log in to view
3
3/0
2
5,071SF
5430 Osprey Ct
08/14/2018
217073248
$539,900
$Log in to view
3
2/0
3
4,582SF
5306 Ladyfinger Lake Rd
08/06/2018
218001327
$1,349,000
$Log in to view
4
2/0
2
5,719SF
1995 My Tern Ct
06/12/2018
217078275
$675,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
2
5,599SF
5280 Umbrella Pool Rd
04/27/2018
216080398
$1,195,000
$Log in to view
4
3/0
2
5,122SF
5403 Shearwater Dr
04/26/2018
217073653
$649,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
3
2,635SF
5301 Ladyfinger Lake Rd
03/20/2018
217007354
$849,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
2
6,909SF
5415 Osprey Ct
03/19/2018
216077986
$649,900
$Log in to view
3
3/0
2
6,398SF
1943 Sanibel Bayou Rd
03/05/2018
217063102
$465,000
$Log in to view
2
2/0
2
1,374SF
4606 Brainard Bayou Rd
01/12/2018
217059340
$569,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
0
3,970SF
5292 Umbrella Pool Rd
01/02/2018
217056167
$579,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
4,837SF
5305 Umbrella Pool Rd
10/30/2017
216074885
$578,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
5,070SF
5308 Umbrella Pool Rd
06/08/2017
216080211
$695,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
4,695SF
5305 Ladyfinger Lake Rd
05/11/2017
216022991
$549,900
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
3,869SF
4619 Brainard Bayou Rd
04/27/2017
216080827
$889,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
3
5,839SF
5406 Osprey Ct
02/28/2017
216017808
$648,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
4,816SF
5279 Umbrella Pool Rd
12/28/2016
215072736
$649,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
3
4,479SF
5303 Ladyfinger Lake Rd
05/27/2016
215048401
$794,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
5,268SF
5267 Ladyfinger Lake Rd
05/27/2016
215065027
$579,900
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
6,798SF
4563 Brainard Bayou Rd
03/28/2016
215052058
$989,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
0
5,034SF
5436 Shearwater Dr
01/22/2016
215052141
$579,000
$Log in to view
3
2/1
2
3,369SF
2065 Wild Lime Dr
01/05/2016
214068065
$729,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
5,839SF
5406 Osprey Ct
09/14/2015
214063455
$529,000
$Log in to view
4
2/2
2
7,763SF
4599 Brainard Bayou Rd
01/16/2015
214053369
$1,247,200
$Log in to view
3
3/1
2
7,312SF
5427 Osprey Ct
12/15/2014
214040820
$829,000
$Log in to view
4
3/0
3
6,604SF
1901 Sanibel Bayou Rd
12/10/2014
214046992
$399,000
$Log in to view
2
1/0
2
1,360SF
4606 Brainard Bayou Rd
11/25/2014
214016181
$595,000
$Log in to view
3
2/1
2
4,811SF
5307 Ladyfinger Lake Rd
04/30/2014
The data relating to homes for sale or lease or other real estate for sale or for rent on the ZFC website comes in part from a cooperative data exchange program of the MLS in which this Broker participates. The real estate displayed may not be all of the homes in the database, or all of the properties listed with Brokers participating in the cooperative data exchange program. Homes for sale that are listed by Brokers other than this Broker are marked with either the listing Broker's name or the MLS name or a logo provided by the MLS and the details page about such properties includes the name of the listing Brokers. Information provided is thought to be reliable but is not guaranteed to be accurate; you are advised to verify facts that are important to you. No warranties, expressed or implied, are provided for the data herein, or for their use or interpretation by the user. ZFC, the Florida Association of Realtors and its cooperating Multiple Listing Services do not create, control or review the property data displayed herein and take no responsibility for the content of such records. Federal law including the fair housing act prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin in the sale, rental or financing of housing. IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
