Sanibel Highlands

Sanibel Highlands is a community of single family homes in Sanibel, Florida, with a range of options priced between $425,000 and $991,714. There are currently a total of 8 homes for sale in Sanibel Highlands. The smallest Sanibel Highlands home presently available is a two bedroom one bathroom residence that is 1,124 square feet (875SF Under Air living space), and the largest of the Sanibel Highlands homes currently on the market has four beds and three baths and is a 5,964 square foot (2,048SF Under Air) residence.

Pets are allowed in Sanibel Highlands.

There are three commercial airports that serve Sanibel Highlands - Page Field (FMY), which is sixteen miles away; Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW), which is twenty miles away, and Punta Gorda (PGD), which is 34 miles away.

Sanibel Highlands real estate activity on the Sanibel MLS during the past year (as of November 2025) reflects three homes changing hands, with an average asking price of $933,500 and an average selling price of $873,333. This represents a healthy list-to-sell price ratio of 94% and $187 per square foot. During this period, Sanibel Highlands homes for sale have taken an average of 88 days to sell.

In addition, there are numerous other communities in Sanibel to choose from, or you may browse all available Sanibel Real Estate, including some new construction opportunities. Homes for sale in Sanibel Highlands are selling quickly. Set up a new listing alert, and we will notify you immediately when a new home in Sanibel Highlands hits the market. You can also always contact your ZFC Real Estate agent, who would happily assist you further with all your real estate needs on Florida's southwest coast.

Sanibel Highlands Homes For Sale

Under Contract

$991,714

MLS#2025010281

1714 Atlanta Plaza Dr
Sanibel, FL 33957

4

3

2

5,899 SqFt

Pool

0.39 Acres

44 Days

Under Contract

$975,000

$1,050,000

MLS#225007375

485 Peachtree Rd
Sanibel, FL 33957

3

3

2

5,964 SqFt

Pool

0.375 Acres

297 Days

Reduced

$749,000

$799,000

MLS#225016666

490 Marian Rd
Sanibel, FL 33957

2

2

1,124 SqFt

Pool

0.52 Acres

202 Days

$674,000

MLS#2025003218

1657 Atlanta Plaza Dr
Sanibel, FL 33957

3

2

1,650 SqFt

0.13 Acres

313 Days

$550,000

MLS#2025005104

1683 Atlanta Plaza Dr
Sanibel, FL 33957

3

2

1,465 SqFt

0.117 Acres

94 Days

Reduced

$524,900

$559,900

MLS#225059092

531 Birdsong Pl
Sanibel, FL 33957

3

2

1,515 SqFt

0.137 Acres

118 Days

$455,000

MLS#225056211

1672 Atlanta Plaza Dr
Sanibel, FL 33957

2

1

1

2,027 SqFt

0.121 Acres

549 Days

$425,000

MLS#2025004407

1653 Atlanta Plaza Dr
Sanibel, FL 33957

2

2

1,200 SqFt

0.123 Acres

94 Days

8 Active Listings in Sanibel Highlands