Homes Sold in Sanibel Highlands
Average List Price$655,014
Average Sold Price$622,523
List/Sell Ratio95%
Average Size2,941 Square Feet
Average Days On Market170
Average Price Per Square Foot$212
Note: Because our historical sales data goes back as far as 10 years or more, keep in mind the statistical figures above reflect the averages of this entire period of time. Current market conditions can vary greatly from these averages.
Notify me when new listings become available in Sanibel Highlands
Your Home's Market Value
Enter Your Address for a free, professional price analysis of your home.
Sanibel Highlands Closed Sales
MLS Number
List Price
Sale Price
Bed
Bth
Cars
Size
Location
Sale Date
224096935
$875,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
3,878SF
499 Leather Fern Pl
05/02/2025
225017189
$1,287,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
3
5,912SF
595 Birdsong Pl
05/01/2025
224089295
$638,500
$Log in to view
3
3/0
1
4,198SF
490 + 460 Old Trail Rd
01/08/2025
224083237
$350,000
$Log in to view
2
2/0
0
1,365SF
530 Leather Fern Pl
11/12/2024
224053819
$650,000
$Log in to view
3
2/1
1
3,664SF
490 + 460 Old Trail Rd
09/23/2024
223080496
$639,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
0
2,460SF
560 Piedmont Rd
06/06/2024
223028832
$549,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
0
1,725SF
530 Piedmont Rd
08/25/2023
223013941
$975,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
0
3,320SF
540 E Lake Rd
08/22/2023
223002527
$595,000
$Log in to view
2
2/0
0
1,998SF
450 Birdsong Pl
08/01/2023
223014572
$550,000
$Log in to view
2
2/0
0
1,493SF
470 Birdsong Pl
06/14/2023
222088167
$799,000
$Log in to view
1
1/1
0
2,820SF
458 Casa Ybel Rd
02/21/2023
222052061
$799,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
0
1,515SF
531 Birdsong Pl
09/08/2022
222047406
$1,250,000
$Log in to view
3
2/1
0
3,327SF
458 Casa Ybel Rd
08/10/2022
221080257
$675,000
$Log in to view
3
2/1
0
1,740SF
534 Piedmont Rd
01/04/2022
221078993
$650,000
$Log in to view
2
1/1
1
1,430SF
1667 Atlanta Plaza Dr
12/30/2021
221056583
$695,555
$Log in to view
3
2/0
0
1,365SF
535 Birdsong Pl
10/29/2021
221040920
$550,000
$Log in to view
2
2/0
2
2,890SF
1717 Atlanta Plaza Dr
06/30/2021
221033085
$765,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
2,968SF
555 Piedmont Rd
06/24/2021
221012770
$749,000
$Log in to view
3
2/1
0
3,327SF
458 Casa Ybel Rd
03/31/2021
220080634
$629,000
$Log in to view
3
2/1
0
3,421SF
430 Old Trail Rd
03/12/2021
220001879
$425,000
$Log in to view
2
1/1
1
1,430SF
1667 Atlanta Plaza Dr
12/31/2020
220052968
$699,900
$Log in to view
3
2/1
1
4,198SF
460 + 490 Old Trail Rd
10/15/2020
220005434
$460,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
0
2,460SF
560 Piedmont Rd
09/23/2020
220009128
$474,000
$Log in to view
2
2/0
0
961SF
499 Peachtree Rd
06/30/2020
220022167
$399,900
$Log in to view
2
1/1
1
1,430SF
1677 Atlanta Plaza Dr
06/12/2020
219078430
$629,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
0
1,647SF
550 Leather Fern Pl
06/12/2020
219075537
$499,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
0
1,650SF
1657 Atlanta Plaza Dr
06/04/2020
219027678
$495,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
0
2,236SF
398 Old Trail Rd
07/02/2019
219029328
$679,000
$Log in to view
3
2/1
0
3,112SF
458 Casa Ybel Rd
06/20/2019
1037413
$234,900
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2,842SF
112 N Cory Drive
05/31/2019
218046215
$439,500
$Log in to view
3
2/0
0
1,377SF
531 Piedmont Rd
02/13/2019
218032755
$420,000
$Log in to view
2
2/0
0
1,486SF
1717 Atlanta Plaza Dr
11/09/2018
217030827
$595,900
$Log in to view
3
2/0
3
3,485SF
545 Piedmont Rd
01/24/2018
216076249
$449,900
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
3,543SF
1817 Atlanta Plaza Dr
01/22/2018
217021992
$2,195,000
$Log in to view
4
4/1
3
9,852SF
390 Old Trail Rd
09/01/2017
216010390
$499,999
$Log in to view
3
2/0
0
1,365SF
535 Birdsong Pl
06/30/2016
216005582
$699,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
1
8,329SF
480 Peachtree Rd
06/15/2016
216009447
$849,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
3
7,000SF
595 Birdsong Pl
06/01/2016
215051043
$425,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
2,424SF
575 Piedmont Rd
05/31/2016
215046946
$479,000
$Log in to view
2
2/0
2
2,612SF
1644 Atlanta Plaza Dr
10/08/2015
214025847
$569,555
$Log in to view
2
2/0
0
2,650SF
490 Christine Rd
02/11/2015
214004001
$379,000
$Log in to view
2
2/0
0
3,800SF
490 Elizabeth Rd
09/03/2014
201327830
$499,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
0
1,748SF
398 Old Trail Rd
01/17/2014
The data relating to homes for sale or lease or other real estate for sale or for rent on the ZFC website comes in part from a cooperative data exchange program of the MLS in which this Broker participates. The real estate displayed may not be all of the homes in the database, or all of the properties listed with Brokers participating in the cooperative data exchange program. Homes for sale that are listed by Brokers other than this Broker are marked with either the listing Broker's name or the MLS name or a logo provided by the MLS and the details page about such properties includes the name of the listing Brokers. Information provided is thought to be reliable but is not guaranteed to be accurate; you are advised to verify facts that are important to you. No warranties, expressed or implied, are provided for the data herein, or for their use or interpretation by the user. ZFC, the Florida Association of Realtors and its cooperating Multiple Listing Services do not create, control or review the property data displayed herein and take no responsibility for the content of such records. Federal law including the fair housing act prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin in the sale, rental or financing of housing. IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
