Homes Sold in Bay Island
Average List Price$3,005,482
Average Sold Price$2,785,431
List/Sell Ratio93%
Average Size5,756 Square Feet
Average Days On Market159
Average Price Per Square Foot$511
Note: Because our historical sales data goes back as far as 10 years or more, keep in mind the statistical figures above reflect the averages of this entire period of time. Current market conditions can vary greatly from these averages.
Notify me when new listings become available in Bay Island
Your Home's Market Value
Enter Your Address for a free, professional price analysis of your home.
Bay Island Closed Sales
MLS Number
List Price
Sale Price
Bed
Bth
Cars
Size
Location
Sale Date
MFRA4635011
$1,300,000
$Log in to view
4
3/0
3,242SF
624 Norsota Way
09/08/2025
MFRA4658433
$799,000
$Log in to view
4
3/0
2
1,537SF
3480 Anglin Dr
07/31/2025
MFRA4637177
$1,700,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
3,183SF
527 Freeling Dr
04/18/2025
MFRA4638005
$1,200,000
$Log in to view
3
3/1
2
3,818SF
3455 Anglin Dr
04/14/2025
MFRA4630576
$1,750,000
$Log in to view
2
2/0
2
2,775SF
530 Freeling Dr
04/10/2025
MFRA4635513
$2,300,000
$Log in to view
3
3/1
2
3,162SF
3532 Flamingo Ave
03/17/2025
MFRA4628296
$895,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
2,582SF
838 Norsota Way
03/12/2025
MFRJ987038
$2,100,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
4,188SF
3820 Flamingo Ave
02/28/2025
MFRA4628643
$3,000,000
$Log in to view
4
4/1
2
4,472SF
864 Siesta Dr
01/29/2025
MFRU8247711
$3,000,000
$Log in to view
3
3/1
2
4,873SF
548 Siesta Dr
12/20/2024
MFRA4616037
$5,900,000
$Log in to view
4
4/1
3
11,977SF
931 Norsota Way
12/17/2024
MFRA4602754
$2,500,000
$Log in to view
4
2/1
2
3,500SF
3458 Anglin Dr
08/28/2024
MFRA4562249
$899,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
1,202SF
831 Siesta Dr
07/30/2024
MFRA4596611
$9,975,000
$Log in to view
5
3/2
4
11,422SF
799 Freeling Dr
05/15/2024
MFRA4602572
$8,250,000
$Log in to view
4
3/0
5,662SF
609 Norsota Way
05/15/2024
MFRA4603315
$3,525,000
$Log in to view
5
5/1
3
5,704SF
604 Norsota Way
04/30/2024
MFRA4599573
$4,350,000
$Log in to view
5
4/1
2
5,315SF
3650 Flamingo Ave
03/25/2024
MFRA4594540
$5,000,000
$Log in to view
5
5/1
2
5,550SF
832 Freeling Dr
03/15/2024
MFRA4596461
$1,329,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
1
2,568SF
3472 Anglin Dr
03/11/2024
MFRA4546740
$6,750,000
$Log in to view
5
5/2
3
7,717SF
3722 Flamingo Ave
03/01/2024
MFRA4568874
$1,675,000
$Log in to view
4
3/0
2
2,765SF
763 Siesta Dr
01/08/2024
MFRA4587780
$4,100,000
$Log in to view
4
3/1
3
6,683SF
722 Siesta Dr
01/04/2024
MFRJ968535
$3,273,110
$Log in to view
4
4/1
4
5,220SF
3409 Seagrape Dr
11/09/2023
MFRA4560510
$3,100,000
$Log in to view
6
3/1
2
6,035SF
746 Siesta Dr
09/13/2023
MFRA4550987
$4,550,000
$Log in to view
3
3/1
4
8,439SF
3726 Flamingo Ave
08/09/2023
MFRA4568181
$2,390,000
$Log in to view
5
4/1
2
3,355SF
3435 Seagrape Dr
06/26/2023
MFRA4534680
$12,600,000
$Log in to view
5
4/2
4
14,436SF
4001 Flamingo Ave
06/02/2023
MFRA4543853
$3,800,000
$Log in to view
4
3/2
2
0SF
3810 Flamingo Ave
03/31/2023
MFRA4557968
$2,350,000
$Log in to view
3
3/1
2
3,818SF
3455 Anglin Dr
03/09/2023
MFRJ957450
$1,950,000
$Log in to view
2
2/0
1
2,887SF
3550 Flamingo Ave
01/27/2023
MFRA4542278
$6,000,000
$Log in to view
4
4/2
3
9,717SF
778 Siesta Dr
12/12/2022
MFRA4526353
$5,250,000
$Log in to view
4
3/1
3
7,446SF
3535 Flamingo Ave
05/11/2022
MFRA4525695
$6,000,000
$Log in to view
4
4/1
2
0SF
852 Freeling Dr
04/27/2022
MFRA4528533
$2,450,000
$Log in to view
4
3/1
2
4,802SF
657 Siesta Dr
04/19/2022
MFRA4525317
$1,350,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
3
7,244SF
3484 Hamilton Ave
04/04/2022
MFRA4523609
$4,000,000
$Log in to view
4
4/1
2
5,156SF
847 Freeling Dr
03/24/2022
MFRA4517581
$3,350,000
$Log in to view
3
3/1
2
4,144SF
3532 Flamingo Ave
12/27/2021
MFRA4510375
$975,000
$Log in to view
5
4/0
0SF
617 Siesta Dr
12/10/2021
MFRA4513144
$6,400,000
$Log in to view
5
5/2
2
7,903SF
880 Siesta Dr
11/23/2021
MFRA4505883
$5,200,000
$Log in to view
4
3/1
3
8,629SF
3482 Flamingo Ave
10/15/2021
MFRA4197137
$1,995,000
$Log in to view
4
4/1
2
5,810SF
878 Siesta Dr
08/03/2018
MFRA4205923
$597,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
2,227SF
779 Siesta Dr
05/08/2018
MFRA4210621
$1,975,000
$Log in to view
3
3/1
2
4,472SF
864 Siesta Drive
04/23/2018
MFRA4206944
$489,900
$Log in to view
2
2/0
1
1,831SF
3472 Anglin Dr
02/26/2018
MFRA4169257
$2,249,900
$Log in to view
4
3/1
3
6,683SF
722 Siesta Dr
11/17/2017
MFRA4172972
$824,900
$Log in to view
4
3/1
2
3,288SF
708 Norsota Way
10/13/2017
MFRA4155197
$2,224,000
$Log in to view
4
3/2
2
4,892SF
3810 Flamingo Ave
02/23/2017
MFRA4167061
$2,395,000
$Log in to view
5
6/1
3
7,363SF
826 Norsota Way
02/01/2017
MFRA4142477
$2,950,000
$Log in to view
4
4/1
2
5,601SF
852 Freeling Dr
09/19/2016
MFRD5900495
$459,000
$Log in to view
3
4/0
1
3,748SF
3459 Seagrape Dr
11/26/2015
MFRA4111214
$5,290,000
$Log in to view
5
6/1
5
13,371SF
901 Norsota Way
09/25/2015
MFRA3989373
$3,600,000
$Log in to view
4
2/1
3
9,628SF
749 Freeling Dr
08/18/2015
MFRA4114857
$2,399,000
$Log in to view
6
4/1
2
5,315SF
3650 Flamingo Ave
08/12/2015
MFRA4114636
$1,995,000
$Log in to view
4
3/1
3
4,961SF
638 Siesta Dr
08/03/2015
MFRA4113698
$810,000
$Log in to view
3
3/1
2
4,316SF
3438 Anglin Dr
07/31/2015
MFRA4115375
$468,900
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
7,244SF
3484 Hamilton Ave
04/06/2015
MFRA3986351
$925,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
2
0SF
546 Freeling Dr
01/16/2015
MFRA3993969
$3,950,000
$Log in to view
4
4/2
3
9,717SF
778 Siesta Dr
09/12/2014
MFRA3996724
$2,440,000
$Log in to view
4
5/1
2
3,898SF
707 Norsota Way
08/20/2014
MFRA3986497
$1,999,000
$Log in to view
4
3/2
2
4,892SF
3810 Flamingo Ave
07/07/2014
MFRA3973944
$4,395,000
$Log in to view
5
6/4
3
12,023SF
684 Freeling Dr
05/29/2014
MFRA3971493
$1,999,999
$Log in to view
5
4/1
3
5,488SF
832 Freeling Dr
05/01/2014
MFRA3975268
$2,395,000
$Log in to view
4
4/1
3
5,133SF
880 Siesta Dr
04/25/2014
MFRA3989976
$1,890,000
$Log in to view
4
4/2
2
6,328SF
762 Siesta Dr
04/18/2014
MFRA3966669
$2,575,000
$Log in to view
4
4/1
2
3,898SF
707 Norsota Way
12/13/2013
MFRA3937986
$1,399,000
$Log in to view
3
3/0
3
4,969SF
622 Siesta Dr
08/05/2013
MFRA3962755
$1,690,000
$Log in to view
4
4/1
2
4,400SF
847 Freeling Dr
06/27/2013
MFRA3965384
$999,000
$Log in to view
4
3/1
2
4,717SF
809 Freeling Dr
03/11/2013
MFRA3971433
$479,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
2
2,425SF
3450 Hamilton Ave
03/04/2013
MFRA3970457
$1,399,000
$Log in to view
5
5/1
3
5,704SF
604 Norsota Way
02/28/2013
MFRA3954389
$12,500,000
$Log in to view
7
8/1
4
9,750SF
3410 Flamingo Ave
02/25/2013
MFRA3954666
$3,100,000
$Log in to view
4
3/1
3
10,467SF
750 Freeling Dr
06/28/2012
MFRA3956497
$595,000
$Log in to view
3
2/0
3,031SF
730 Freeling Dr
05/31/2012
MFRA3936671
$3,499,000
$Log in to view
4
4/1
3
11,569SF
931 Norsota Way
05/09/2012
MFRA3933361
$1,850,000
$Log in to view
4
5/0
2
5,835SF
897 Freeling Dr
04/17/2012
MFRA3950111
$329,900
$Log in to view
3
2/1
6,290SF
3445 Anglin Dr
01/04/2012
The data relating to homes for sale or lease or other real estate for sale or for rent on the ZFC website comes in part from a cooperative data exchange program of the MLS in which this Broker participates. The real estate displayed may not be all of the homes in the database, or all of the properties listed with Brokers participating in the cooperative data exchange program. Homes for sale that are listed by Brokers other than this Broker are marked with either the listing Broker's name or the MLS name or a logo provided by the MLS and the details page about such properties includes the name of the listing Brokers. Information provided is thought to be reliable but is not guaranteed to be accurate; you are advised to verify facts that are important to you. No warranties, expressed or implied, are provided for the data herein, or for their use or interpretation by the user. ZFC, the Florida Association of Realtors and its cooperating Multiple Listing Services do not create, control or review the property data displayed herein and take no responsibility for the content of such records. Federal law including the fair housing act prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin in the sale, rental or financing of housing. IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
