Sutton Preserve

Sutton Preserve is a community of single family homes in Winter Haven, Florida, with a range of options priced between $300,000 and $364,999. There are currently a total of 5 homes for sale in Sutton Preserve. The smallest Sutton Preserve home presently available is a three bedroom two bathroom residence that is 2,470 square feet (1,928SF Under Air living space), and the largest of the Sutton Preserve homes currently on the market has four beds and three baths and is a 2,614 square foot (2,070SF Under Air) residence.

Property management fees in Polk County vary depending on the community and sometimes vary between homes in the community. The current HOA fees for homes in Sutton Preserve range from $800 to $1,069. Please check the individual listing pages for the exact homeowners association fees for a particular Sutton Preserve home.

The Sutton Preserve HOA rules do allow homeowners to have pets. Dogs and cats are allowed.

There are four commercial airports that serve Sutton Preserve - Lakeland Linder International (LAL), which is seventeen miles away; Kissimmee Gateway (ISM), which is twenty nine miles away; Orlando International (MCO), which is 41 miles away, and Orlando Executive (ORL), which is 47 miles away from Sutton Preserve.

Sutton Preserve real estate activity on the Winter Haven MLS during the past year (as of February 2026) reflects 32 homes changing hands, with an average asking price of $345,924 and an average selling price of $340,809. This represents a healthy list-to-sell price ratio of 99% and $143 per square foot. During this period, Sutton Preserve homes for sale have taken an average of a long 210 or more days to sell.

In addition, there are numerous other communities in Winter Haven to choose from, or you may browse all available Winter Haven Real Estate, including some new construction opportunities. Homes for sale in Sutton Preserve are selling quickly. Set up a new listing alert, and we will notify you immediately when a new home in Sutton Preserve hits the market. You can also always contact your ZFC Real Estate agent, who would happily assist you further with all your Central Florida real estate needs.

Sutton Preserve Homes For Sale

Reduced

$364,999

$400,992

MLS#MFRS5114491

2007 Stetson Ave
Eagle Lake, FL 33839

3

2

3

2,560 SqFt

0.13 Acres

465 Days

New Construction

Reduced

$339,999

$351,749

MLS#MFRS5137892

2516 Ashley Way
Eagle Lake, FL 33839

4

3

2

2,470 SqFt

0.15 Acres

90 Days

New Construction

Under Contract

$339,950

$357,407

MLS#MFRS5109089

2043 Stetson Ct
Eagle Lake, FL 33839

4

3

2

2,470 SqFt

0.15 Acres

559 Days

New Construction

Under Contract

$324,950

$363,907

MLS#MFRS5109923

2027 Stetson Ct
Eagle Lake, FL 33839

4

3

2

2,470 SqFt

0.15 Acres

545 Days

New Construction

Reduced

$300,000

$340,000

MLS#MFRL4957439

2869 Cathy Blvd
Winter Haven, FL 33880

4

2

2

2,614 SqFt

0.13 Acres

74 Days

5 Active Listings in Sutton Preserve